What is American Soccer?

by Dr. Jay Martin

American soccer has an inferiority complex.

We have been told for so many years that we are not good enough that we now believe it!!   We don’t have the technique of Brazil; the savvy of Germany; the awareness of France; the pace of England or the youth system of Holland. We really think we are no good!!

Maybe the week of February 26, 2001 will help dispel that notion and change some minds.   It was the week the US National Team defeated Mexico 2-0 in Columbus and lost to Brazil 1-2 in Los Angeles.   It was not the results that are overly significant – the results were great – but, it was the way the team played that is truly meaningful.    Here we begin to define an American style of soccer.   We found a way of playing that is – well – American in every aspect!

In Columbus the Mexicans found very cold weather AND a pretty good team.   A team that faced some adversity (after the top two players went out with injury), played very well together, defended well, worked extremely hard, did exactly what the coach wanted (and the team needed), and used athletic ability to win the game. These are all characteristics of American athletes! In fact, in the post game news conference,  Coach Bruce Arena said, “We thought the speed and quickness of Wolf would be a factor in tonight’s game.”  Aren’t these the characteristics of the American soccer player?  Aren’t these characteristics of the American athlete?   The US team used precisely these characteristics to play tough against a very good Brazilian team later in the week.

You would not call the style of the USA team that night Brazilian, German, Dutch or French. You would not say the American team overly possessed the ball, or that great technique carried the day.  But, you would say that the Americans earned three points and beat their biggest rival for the third straight game.  You would say the Americans worked hard, defended, used athleticism, were disciplined and used speed to score two good goals.

You might say the team won the “American Way”!

The same day the Germans lost 1-0 to France on an early goal by Zinedine Zidane. His comments? “It is true that it could have been a more spectacular game, but you have to win the game physically above all.  We stopped them from playing their game and didn’t give them much room.”   The French have their game, the Germans have theirs, is is possible that we finally have ours?

The Evolution of US Soccer

The History of US Soccer is that of imitation. We have tried to imitate almost every soccer playing nation at one time or another. We imitated them because we were not any good. Coaches from all over the world told us that we were no good.  It is true that the soccer playing world takes lessons from every World Cup.  Nations analyze the winning team and try to determine if there is something that will make them better. In many World Cup tournaments there is some good stuff (1958, 1966, 1974, 1998). In some World Cup finals there is not too much (1978, 1990). However, most nations have tried 4-4-2, 4-3-3 and 3-5-2 as displayed by different Cup winners. But, most soccer playing nations have a very definable style within their tactical alignment. The classic documentary of the 1982 World Cup Gole clearly depicts these styles both visually and musically.  These nations never had to imitate each other!   US Soccer did because, well you know, we were not any good.

We tried to be Brazilians as we learned to juggle in the early seventies. We tried to be the English as Charles Hughes told us to direct four quick passes into the POMO (position of maximum opportunity!) in order to score. We tried to possess like Germany under the direction of Heddergott and Cramer. We tried to be Dutch and did Coerver moves so we could be comfortable on the ball. We tried to copy youth systems from everywhere.

Nothing worked!

In fact, most of these “soccer fads” hurt the evolution and growth of American soccer. Many of theses aspects of soccer (juggling, Coerver moves etc.) became and end instead of a means to an end!!  We spent all of our time discovering what we can not do instead of what we can do….which is very un-American!!

Soccer experts from all over the globe spent a great deal of time and money telling us why we are not good soccer players and what we could not do! We spent the 50’s, 60’s 70’s and 80’s changing methods, tactics and styles. We were actually surprised if we won an international match. We were no good. Our inferiority complex grew larger.

Even U20 coach Wolfgang Suhnholz in a recent interview on internetsoccer.com when asked about US player development said, “We went through a lot of stages here; we were trying to copy everybody.  Brazil was world champions and we tried to play Brazilian. Germany was world champions and we all looked to Germany.  We forgot that we have to create our own environment. We have to use our own players. We have to use the attributes of American players, and we have been doing that now for a few years. Success has shown.”

The fact of the matter is we are Americans. We are not Brazilians, Germans,
Dutch, or French. We cannot play soccer with the style of those countries. It is simply not possible.

It is impossible for us to replicate the Brazilian culture and society. The culture and society influence, no, dictate, how the Brazilians play.  The social, economic, political and cultural forces directly impact how any national team plays.   Nor can we replicate the club systems of England and Germany; nor the youth system of France and Holland.

American soccer is unique. America is unique.

We can and should learn from other soccer nations, but we should develop and play an American style. There is no question that there is a great deal to learn from other soccer playing nations. We should, however, take these lessons and use them in the context of an American style.

FlagThe American Style: A Definition

What is an American style? That is hard to define. But, the style is beginning to develop.   A recent and very unscientific survey asked the following question to over five hundred soccer people: What are the top three or four most positive characteristics of the American soccer player?  The respondents covered all aspects of soccer from a variety of countries; fans, players of all levels, coaches, administrators and journalists. The results were interesting and somewhat predictable.   Soccer people from near and far agree that the top four characteristics of the American soccer player are:

  1. Athletic Ability (speed, fitness, strength etc.)
  2. Attitude (competitiveness, desire, enthusiasm, toughness etc.) 
  3. Work rate (effort, aggressiveness, hustle etc.)
  4. Coachability

There were other characteristics mentioned such as teamwork, technical ability and goalkeeping, but the aforementioned are the top four in rank order. If a similar question was asked of Brazilian or German soccer players the results would be different.

These attributes are found in all American athletes not just soccer players.  The American athlete is unique. That should make American soccer unique.  And these attributes should serve as the common denominator for an American soccer style.

A recent ODP Region II Symposium addressed these issues specifically. When reviewing the performance of each regional team, the list included such attributes as listed above. One emphatic addition was a strong desire to play well and to WIN!!!   That is very American.

The Win v “Good Soccer” Dilemma

That suggests another American soccer problem…the win v (perceived) good soccer dilemma. At the upper level of soccer (college, club, international etc.) winning is the goal. In a recent article in Soccer America Paul Gardner describes the Brazilians as soccer’s standard because “They have done it on the field, with a record of (winning) world championships at all levels and versions of the game – from futsal and U17 World Cups up to the big one itself – that no other country comes close to matching.” He did not say HOW the Brazilians win…he said they win!!

Winning, then, dictates the how a team is ranked internationally!

Youth soccer should NOT emphasize winning. Hans Westerhof the Director of Youth Coaching at Ajax agrees “…from eight to fifteen is time to develop youth players… and only develop, but at sixteen you MUST win.” We do just the opposite. Win, win, win in youth soccer and then emphasize the way we play as the players get older!! Often losing is justified because “…we possessed the ball for sixty minutes” or “…we played better soccer, but were unlucky.” No other postgame comments in American sport are defined in that manner. Have you ever heard the Super Bowl loser say “…we really outplayed them and they were lucky to win”?

American soccer has searched for “good soccer” or “appealing soccer” or “internationally acceptable soccer” at the expense of winning. We have been apologetic about the way we play. But if Brazil sets the standard by winning, then winning is important. The national team beat Mexico using American strengths.

American soccer will earn international respect when winning becomes commonplace.

Away with Technique?

Does this mean we discard all technical work in training and have the soccer athletes run all day?? Of course not. The American player IS technical. The American player can compete technically with players from all over the world in the U12-U18 range.  The technical aspect of the sport is essential. But, we will never play technically like Brazil!  In order for American soccer to move forward, we must realize and accept this fact.

Euro 2000 showed clearly that soccer at the highest level is changing.  According to the FIFA summary; the speed of play increased, there were more long passes, physical demands increased and the build up is gone. The days when four backs possess and build up slowly against two front runners is behind us. Today soccer at the highest level demands that the ball is played forward…quickly and over a distance. This does not suggest that possession is dead. It has been replaced by “vertical possession” get the ball forward and possess in your attacking half!! This demands even better (quicker) technique not less technique. And, this is exactly what the men’s national team did against Mexico and Brazil. Americans are aggressive, we like to attack…let’s attack. In fact, the style of play that Americans have used in previous international competitions has been the classic defend and counter. As recently as 1998, the national team played a 3-6-1. Sit in and counter …this, too, is decidedly un-American. We did not play to our strengths. It is difficult for Americans to “sit in”. We are aggressive in all aspects of our culture. Where was the good old American arrogance? We are starting to see it now.

The Brazilians did possess the ball in Los Angeles against the national team. But the possession was most often in the back against the forwards. When Brazil went forward the US defense did a pretty good job containing one of the best teams in the world. And, when the US won the ball they went forward quickly. In fact the goal against Brazil was a classic example of the US team moving forward with possession and putting pressure on the Brazilians. Both Paul Gardner (in an internetsoccer.com article about how the French combine athleticism and skill) and Aime Jacquet (in a FIFA interview) concede that “…the new demands of the game (include), becoming more tactical and more athletic.” This is soccer at the highest level. American soccer should continue to improve technique, but also emphasize the physical/athletic. If Americans can match up physically/athletically first there is a chance to be successful. And, at the international level success means winning.

The Training Session

Possession is not gone. But, the possession “in the back’ with the slow build up is gone. Possession must be practiced moving the ball forward with speed. Possession must have a purpose! Training sessions should incorporate the following:

  • Improvement is all aspects and types of passing with emphasis on passes of twenty yards and more
  • Switching the field of play quickly and accuratelly
  • Possession in the attacking half. That means possession sessions should be closer to even numbers and not situations where the attackers outnumber defenders by as much as 2:1.
  • Continue to emphasize and develop American athletic attributes (i.e. attacking mentality, hard work, defending etc.)
  • Practice technique in tight spaces or by manipulating time and space to add pressure to the situation

American soccer is better than most of the so called experts think. It is time to eliminate the inferiority complex and begin to recognize and define an American style. Coaches should develop an open mind and understand that there are many ways to be successful (win) in soccer. When we listen to world class coaches like Carlos Perriera of Brazil or Roger LeMerre of France tells us about the Brazilian or French system, we must ask what can we use to make our players better…but, understand that the information will not make the players play like the Brazilians or French. The time is here to define an American style. Bruce Arena and the US National team have started the process. It is now up to each coach to continue the process!!

Posted in Mindset & Stragegy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


eighteen − fifteen =

Event Scheduling

Make an impact with Dr. Martin at your next event.
  • Get Focused
  • Be Motivated
  • Develop Mental Toughness

Make an Impactat your next event

Your Name (required)
Your Email (required)
Please leave this field empty.
Request Info on:

Most Recent Article

Don't call him 'Coach' The men’s soccer coach at Ohio Wesleyan University for 38 years, Jay Martin started out coaching men’s lacrosse...

Read More


  • Coaching Excellence Coaching Soccer the NSCAA Way: A Complete Guide (Best of Soccer Journal)
    Warning: A non-numeric value encountered in /nfs/c08/h03/mnt/119847/domains/drjaymartin.com/html/wp-content/plugins/woocommerce/includes/abstracts/abstract-wc-product.php on line 940

    Warning: A non-numeric value encountered in /nfs/c08/h03/mnt/119847/domains/drjaymartin.com/html/wp-content/plugins/woocommerce/includes/abstracts/abstract-wc-product.php on line 940
  • best-of-soccer-journal-500 The Best of Soccer Journal - Tactics & Technique
    Warning: A non-numeric value encountered in /nfs/c08/h03/mnt/119847/domains/drjaymartin.com/html/wp-content/plugins/woocommerce/includes/abstracts/abstract-wc-product.php on line 940

    Warning: A non-numeric value encountered in /nfs/c08/h03/mnt/119847/domains/drjaymartin.com/html/wp-content/plugins/woocommerce/includes/abstracts/abstract-wc-product.php on line 940
  • Art-of-coaching Best of Soccer Journal: The Art of Coaching (Nscaa Soccer Coaching)
    Warning: A non-numeric value encountered in /nfs/c08/h03/mnt/119847/domains/drjaymartin.com/html/wp-content/plugins/woocommerce/includes/abstracts/abstract-wc-product.php on line 940

    Warning: A non-numeric value encountered in /nfs/c08/h03/mnt/119847/domains/drjaymartin.com/html/wp-content/plugins/woocommerce/includes/abstracts/abstract-wc-product.php on line 940

Make an Impact

Let Dr. Jay Martin Inspire Your Audience.
  • Get Focused
  • Be Motivated
  • Develop Mental Toughness

Make an Impactat your next event

Your Name (required)
Your Email (required)
Please leave this field empty.
Request Info on: